Select Page

Aloha Faculty Colleagues,

Please take 5 minutes to complete this Peer Evaluation Guidelines survey

While the UHPA contract establishes the importance and the overall process of contract renewal, tenure, and promotion, it does not provide any requirements for peer evaluation in these processes. Instead, the UHPA contract explicitly states that guidelines for these processes will be provided by “the Employer”, i.e., the UH System Administration. The tenure and promotion guidelines include no requirements for peer evaluation; however, the contract renewal guidelines explicitly state that “There should be two (2) peer evaluations for each of the semesters being covered in the evaluation period.” Other than this guidance, there is no further reference to peer evaluation in any of these documents. Therefore:

  • For promotion documents (submitted annually), 4 peer evaluations are necessary;
  • For tenure/ promotion documents, 16 peer evaluations are necessary (4 per year for the first 4 years); and
  • For promotion documents post-tenure, no peer evaluations are necessary.
This guidance has raised a number of concerns:
  1. Some very small departments with few faculty have difficulty providing 2 peer evaluations per semester to faculty colleagues who need contract renewals and regularly have to seek faculty colleagues from outside of their departments/ units to provide peer evaluations. These departments/ units would like to be able to provide peer evaluation materials other than the common peer evaluation of faculty forms (e.g., letters, surveys).
  2. In the guidance statement, the modal verb “should” is legally interpreted as a suggestion, not a requirement, although this guidance is generally thought of by faculty and admin throughout the UH System as a strict requirement.
  3. There are continuing questions about the exact number of peer evaluations required for each of the different documents, including promotion documents post-tenure.
Please answer the survey questions based on your experience with the contact renewal and tenure/ promotion process regarding peer evaluations.
Mahalo!
KapCC Faculty Senate